The rules, and where exchanges fail.
Most failed exchanges do not fail on the big idea. They fail on a date, a signature or a wire. This page goes through each rule and the mistake that usually goes with it.
Current as of November 2026 · Sources linked on this page
Real estate, held for the right reason
Held for investment or business
Rental property, a building your business operates in, or land held as an investment. The test is your purpose in holding it.
Like-kind is broad
Any real estate held for investment or business can be exchanged for any other. Apartments for a warehouse. Land for a shopping centre. A single building for several.
What does not qualify
Your primary residence, property bought to fix and resell, and a developer's inventory. Since 2018, equipment and other personal property do not qualify either.
United States for United States
Property inside the United States is not like-kind to property outside it.
How long must I hold it?
The code sets no minimum holding period. What counts is that you held the old property, and intend to hold the new one, for investment or business use. Ask your tax adviser how your facts look.
Sources IRC §1031 ↗ IRS Publication 544 ↗
Identifying replacement property
In writing, signed, delivered
The identification is a written document that you sign and deliver to your intermediary, or to another person involved in the exchange who is not disqualified, by midnight of day 45.
Described clearly
A street address or legal description. "A warehouse in Lancaster" does not identify anything.
Three-property rule
You may identify up to three properties, whatever they are worth. Most exchangers use this rule.
200% rule
You may identify more than three if their combined value is not more than twice what you sold.
95% rule
If you go beyond both limits, the identification still works only if you actually buy at least 95% of the value identified.
Changing your mind
You can revoke an identification and make a new one in writing until day 45 ends. After that the list is fixed.
Sources Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1 ↗
Closing on the replacement
The exchange period
You must receive the replacement property by the earlier of 180 days after your sale closed, or the due date of your tax return for the year of the sale, including extensions.
The tax return trap
Close a sale in November or December and day 180 lands after April 15. Without an extension, the exchange period ends when the return is due. Filing an extension restores the full 180 days. Check your dates.
No grace days
A deadline that lands on a Saturday, Sunday or holiday stays there. The only extensions are the ones the IRS announces for federally declared disasters.
Buy what you identified
What you close on has to be substantially the same property you identified.
Boot, debt and the intermediary
Do not touch the proceeds
If the sale proceeds reach you, or an account you control, the exchange is over. The intermediary holds them from one closing to the other.
Who cannot be your intermediary
Anyone who has acted as your employee, attorney, accountant, or real estate agent or broker within the two years before the sale is generally disqualified. That includes us.
Cash boot
Any sale proceeds you take out, at closing or after, are taxable up to the amount of your gain.
Debt boot
If the loan on the new property is smaller than the loan paid off on the old one, the difference is treated like cash received, unless you add your own cash to make it up.
The full-deferral test
Buy for at least the net sale price, reinvest all of the net equity, and replace the debt with new debt or added cash. Run your numbers.
Same taxpayer
The seller of the old property takes title to the new one. Changing from your own name to a new partnership mid-exchange can break it.
Related parties
Exchanges with family members or entities you control have extra rules, including a two-year holding requirement for both sides.
Sources Treas. Reg. §1.1031(k)-1 ↗ IRC §1031 ↗ IRS: Form 8824 ↗
Seven ways an exchange fails
| What happens | How to avoid it | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | The intermediary is hired after the sale closes. | Sign the exchange agreement before closing. |
| 2 | The proceeds are wired to the seller. | Escrow instructions name the intermediary. |
| 3 | Day 45 passes with nothing identified in writing. | Start the search before you list, not after you close. |
| 4 | The identification is vague or unsigned. | Address or legal description, signed and delivered. |
| 5 | The return for the year of sale is filed, or comes due, before the purchase closes. | File an extension if day 180 falls after the due date. |
| 6 | The buyer on title is not the seller on title. | Settle how you will hold title before the sale. |
| 7 | The replacement costs less or carries less debt, and nobody ran the numbers. | Check for boot before you make the offer. |
Tell us what you need.
Four short steps. A broker reviews what you send and calls you. Nothing is shared outside the brokerage.
Or call 818-696-0888 · hello@sbzcre.com
